Skip to content 
Single-Family Home Renovation: North American Material Substitution Guide
Planning a home renovation? Smart move! But what if global supply chain issues, like a potential trade embargo with China, affect your material availability? This guide is for the savvy DIYer and small contractor in North America, offering practical alternatives for common renovation materials, helping you keep your project on schedule and on budget with locally sourced or reliable options.
Essential Renovation Materials & Their North American Alternatives
1. Plywood & OSB (Oriented Strand Board)
Typical Source: While North America is a major producer, some specialty panels or lower-cost options might have origins or components from China.
North American Substitute: APA-rated structural panels from established North American mills.
- Look for the APA – The Engineered Wood Association certification stamp on panels; this ensures they meet structural standards for North American construction.
- Specify the correct grade and thickness for your application (e.g., subflooring, wall sheathing, roof decking).
- Major brands like Georgia-Pacific (GP), Weyerhaeuser, and LP Building Solutions have extensive North American production.
Cost Comparison: Domestic structural panels are generally competitively priced. Focusing on APA-certified products ensures quality and adherence to building codes, minimizing risks associated with uncertified imports.
Reputable Source Info:
APA – The Engineered Wood Association (Use APA’s resources to find certified producers and technical information.)2. Drywall (Gypsum Board)
Typical Source: While most drywall in North America is domestically produced, some imported products exist. Past issues with imported drywall highlight the importance of sourcing from reputable manufacturers.
North American Substitute: Leading North American gypsum board manufacturers.
- Ensure you select the correct type for the application: standard for general walls/ceilings, Type X for fire-rated assemblies, moisture/mold-resistant (e.g., “green board” or “purple board”) for bathrooms and damp areas.
- Major brands include USG (Sheetrock®), National Gypsum (Gold Bond®), and CertainTeed.
- Proper installation and finishing are key to a good result.
Cost Comparison: Domestically produced drywall is widely available and competitively priced. The risks associated with uncertified or problematic imported drywall far outweigh any minor cost savings.
Reputable Supplier Example (Manufacturer):
USG Sheetrock® Brand3. Luxury Vinyl Plank (LVP) & Tile Flooring
Typical Source: China is a dominant global producer of LVP and many types of ceramic/porcelain tiles.
North American Substitute:
- LVP: Look for lines from companies like Mohawk, Shaw Floors, Mannington, and Armstrong that are specified as “Made in USA” or “Assembled in USA.”
- Tile: Brands like Daltile and American Olean (both part of Mohawk Industries) have significant U.S. manufacturing operations. Crossville is another notable U.S. tile manufacturer.
- For LVP, check wear layer thickness (e.g., 12mil, 20mil) for durability. “Made in USA” often indicates better quality control and potentially lower VOCs.
- For tile, verify if it’s porcelain (denser, more durable) or ceramic. Look for PTCA (Porcelain Tile Certification Agency) certification for true porcelain.
- Always order 10-15% extra for cuts and future repairs.
Cost Comparison: U.S.-made LVP and tile can be 20-70% more expensive than comparable imported products. This reflects higher labor costs, stricter environmental regulations, and often, superior quality and design consistency.
Reputable Supplier Examples:
Mohawk Flooring (LVP) Daltile (Tile)4. Kitchen & Bath Faucets/Fixtures
Typical Source: A significant number of faucets, showerheads, and other plumbing fixtures, or their components, are manufactured in China.
North American Substitute: Established brands like Moen, Delta, and Kohler. While many of their products involve global components, they often have “Assembled in USA” lines and maintain higher quality control and warranty support from North America. Some smaller boutique brands also offer “Made in USA” options.
- Look for certifications like WaterSense (for water efficiency) and NSF/ANSI 61 (for material safety in contact with drinking water).
- Consider the warranty and ease of obtaining replacement parts (cartridges, seals), which is often better with established North American-serviced brands.
- “Assembled in USA” usually means the final assembly and quality checks are done domestically.
Cost Comparison: “Assembled in USA” fixtures from major brands might be 15-50% more expensive than purely imported, lesser-known brands. Fully U.S.-manufactured fixtures from specialty companies will command a higher premium.
Reputable Supplier Example (Manufacturer):
Delta Faucet5. Cabinetry Hardware (Hinges, Pulls, Drawer Slides)
Typical Source: China is a major global supplier of cabinet hardware, from budget to mid-range.
North American/European Substitute: Brands like Blum (Austrian, strong NA presence, some US production/assembly), Grass (Austrian/German, NA operations), Knape & Vogt (KV – USA), Accuride (USA/Global), and Richelieu (Canadian distributor of many quality NA/European brands).
- For hinges and drawer slides, prioritize quality and durability. Soft-close features are common and desirable.
- Reputable brands often offer lifetime warranties on their mechanisms.
- Pulls and knobs are more aesthetic, but quality finishes will last longer.
- Check load ratings for drawer slides, especially for wide or deep drawers.
Cost Comparison: Quality European and North American hardware brands can be significantly more expensive (50-300%) than generic Chinese imports. However, they offer superior performance, longevity, and smoother operation.
Reputable Supplier Example (Distributor/Manufacturer):
Richelieu Hardware6. PEX Piping & Fittings
Typical Source: While PEX technology originated elsewhere, some PEX tubing and fittings are imported from China.
North American Substitute: Leading brands like Uponor (Wirsbo), Viega, SharkBite (RWC – Reliance Worldwide Corporation), Zurn, and Rehau. Many of these have significant manufacturing and distribution in North America.
- Understand the different types of PEX (PEX-A, PEX-B, PEX-C) and their corresponding fitting systems. Ensure compatibility.
- Look for NSF (nsf-pw for potable water) and ASTM certifications on tubing and fittings.
- Using tools and fittings from the same system/manufacturer is generally recommended for warranty and reliability.
Cost Comparison: Reputable North American or European-designed PEX systems might be 10-35% more expensive than some imported alternatives, but offer proven reliability, technical support, and system warranties.
Reputable Supplier Example (Manufacturer):
Uponor (PEX-A)7. Fiberglass Batt & Blown-In Insulation
Typical Source: The North American market is largely supplied by domestic manufacturers, but raw materials or some niche insulation products could have international components.
North American Substitute: Major manufacturers like Owens Corning, Johns Manville, CertainTeed, and Knauf Insulation all have extensive North American production.
- Select the appropriate R-value based on your local building codes and climate zone. Higher R-value means better thermal resistance.
- Consider unfaced batts if a separate vapor barrier is planned, or faced batts (kraft paper or foil) which can act as a vapor retarder.
- For air quality, look for products with certifications like GREENGUARD Gold.
- Proper installation (avoiding compression and gaps) is crucial for performance.
Cost Comparison: Prices are generally competitive among major North American brands. Supply is typically robust from domestic sources.
Reputable Supplier Example (Manufacturer):
Johns Manville (Residential Insulation)8. Asphalt Roofing Shingles
Typical Source: The vast majority of asphalt shingles sold in North America are manufactured in North America. However, an embargo could potentially affect the supply of certain raw materials (e.g., asphalt modifiers, fillers, granules) if some manufacturers rely on Chinese sources for these components.
North American Substitute: Leading manufacturers such as GAF, Owens Corning, CertainTeed, IKO, and Malarkey all have strong North American manufacturing footprints.
- Choose between traditional 3-tab shingles (more economical) and architectural/laminated shingles (more durable, better aesthetics, longer warranties).
- Pay attention to warranty length, wind rating, and algae resistance features.
- Ensure proper installation including underlayment, starter shingles, and ventilation for warranty validity and roof longevity.
Cost Comparison: The market is dominated by North American players, making direct import of finished shingles uncommon and generally not cost-effective for residential projects. Focus on product features and contractor reputation.
Reputable Supplier Example (Manufacturer):
GAF Residential Roofing9. Interior Molded Panel Doors
Typical Source: Many molded door skins (the outer surfaces) and some core materials for interior doors are manufactured in Asia, including China.
North American Substitute: Major door manufacturers like Jeld-Wen and Masonite have significant North American assembly operations. They often source components globally but offer lines that emphasize North American assembly and meet regional standards.
- Consider solid core doors for better sound insulation and a more substantial feel compared to hollow core, especially for bedrooms and bathrooms.
- Doors are available pre-hung (with frame) or as slabs. Pre-hung doors are often easier for DIY installation.
- Check for different styles (e.g., 2-panel, 6-panel) and smooth or textured finishes.
Cost Comparison: Doors assembled in North America, or those with higher North American content, might be 15-40% more expensive than those heavily reliant on imported components. Solid core options also add to the cost.
Reputable Supplier Example (Manufacturer):
Masonite Interior Doors10. LED Lighting Fixtures (Recessed, Flush Mount, etc.)
Typical Source: China is a primary source for LED components (chips, drivers) and complete lighting fixtures for residential use.
North American Substitute: Look for product lines from companies like Cooper Lighting Solutions (Eaton), Lithonia Lighting (Acuity Brands), GE Lighting (a Savant company), and Philips/Signify that are designated as “Assembled in USA” or have strong North American quality control and support. Many smaller, specialized lighting companies also assemble or design in North America.
- Check for ENERGY STAR certification for energy efficiency.
- Key specifications: Lumens (brightness), Color Temperature (CCT – e.g., 2700K warm, 5000K cool), Color Rendering Index (CRI – 90+ is good for color accuracy).
- Ensure compatibility with dimmer switches if dimming is desired (not all LEDs are dimmable or work well with all dimmers).
- Consider warranty length and driver quality, as the driver is often the first component to fail.
Cost Comparison: LED fixtures assembled in the USA or from reputable brands with strong NA support can be 25-75% more expensive than basic imported fixtures. However, they often offer better performance, longevity, and more reliable warranties.
Reputable Supplier Example (Manufacturer):
Halo (from Cooper Lighting Solutions) (Halo is a popular brand for recessed and track lighting, often available through electrical distributors and home centers.)